Can't imagine hearing anything bad about Noccalula Falls. We have stayed there 3 times and always hated to leave. Have not stayed at the other place so can't comment on it. The Falls is a beautiful setting with a great history of an indian maiden. There is a great paved walking trail that takes off from the falls and winds all the way down the stream for quite a way. Camping fee is really quite reasonable as the falls is owned by the community, but has full hookups and even cable. We definitely stay there every time we are near.