DonTom
Senior Member
RV LIFE Pro
I would like to discuss helpful modifications people have made to anything, RV related or not.
I just came up with this question when I was working on my Y2K RV about an hour ago. I wanted to run the genny, but not even a click. I did the basic troubleshooting, and it took me about five minutes to test, prove defective and remove the Onan starter solenoid. The relay coil is drawing four amps, no click, no continuity between the large posts, and gets warm. I now find the same as I test it indoors, as I expected.
Price from Onan: $73.00 I am not a big believer in OEM parts when other stuff is available. I have found countless cases where much cheaper aftermarket part was MUCH better designed than the OEM that broke.
Price on Amazon for the same ratings, $14.00. I just now purchased a couple to have a spare. Two for less than half the price of one from Onan with the same specs.
Anybody who is familiar with an Onan 4K, still installed in a motorhome will say that is not even possible to remove the solenoid in a few minutes, as I just now did. IIRC, it takes perhaps more than an hour to remove the solenoid that took me a few minutes to remove today.
But the time I removed my genny from my Y2K motorhome, four years ago, I made many modifications. One of them was to mount the solenoid outside the genny cabinet, where it will be easy to get to, but still have reasonable weather protection. Other things I did at that time was to move the Onan fuel pump and control board so I can troubleshoot or replace them in minutes as well. But that stuff is still in the Onan genny cabinet, but in such a way that it only takes seconds to remove and replace.
For non-RV stuff, on my 1984 Venture motorcycle, it normally takes a good day's worth of work to get to the ignition control module. I also moved it to right under the seat, I can change it in one minute, if necessary. That will save me from calling a tow truck because I carry a spare. And makes the entire bike much easier to troubleshoot.
What handy modifications have others made here to help save time for later? RV related or not?
-Don- Auburn, CA
I just came up with this question when I was working on my Y2K RV about an hour ago. I wanted to run the genny, but not even a click. I did the basic troubleshooting, and it took me about five minutes to test, prove defective and remove the Onan starter solenoid. The relay coil is drawing four amps, no click, no continuity between the large posts, and gets warm. I now find the same as I test it indoors, as I expected.
Price from Onan: $73.00 I am not a big believer in OEM parts when other stuff is available. I have found countless cases where much cheaper aftermarket part was MUCH better designed than the OEM that broke.
Price on Amazon for the same ratings, $14.00. I just now purchased a couple to have a spare. Two for less than half the price of one from Onan with the same specs.
Anybody who is familiar with an Onan 4K, still installed in a motorhome will say that is not even possible to remove the solenoid in a few minutes, as I just now did. IIRC, it takes perhaps more than an hour to remove the solenoid that took me a few minutes to remove today.
But the time I removed my genny from my Y2K motorhome, four years ago, I made many modifications. One of them was to mount the solenoid outside the genny cabinet, where it will be easy to get to, but still have reasonable weather protection. Other things I did at that time was to move the Onan fuel pump and control board so I can troubleshoot or replace them in minutes as well. But that stuff is still in the Onan genny cabinet, but in such a way that it only takes seconds to remove and replace.
For non-RV stuff, on my 1984 Venture motorcycle, it normally takes a good day's worth of work to get to the ignition control module. I also moved it to right under the seat, I can change it in one minute, if necessary. That will save me from calling a tow truck because I carry a spare. And makes the entire bike much easier to troubleshoot.
What handy modifications have others made here to help save time for later? RV related or not?
-Don- Auburn, CA