We need to replace the mud flap on our motorhome. An alligator on the interstate did damage to the one we had. Couldn't avoid it and ran right over it. It was stopped by the mudflap and spun out to the side. Did some damage to the wiring (right turn signal on toad doesn't work). Husband would like imput as to what type to get. A solid one (Ultra-Guard - kind we had) or the type that look like rubber strips. Or, maybe none at all?? Pros or cons. Appreciate any imput.