"Yes, they make smart chargers.".
But I was asking about solar controllers, not "chargers". My solar controller reduces the pulse width (mine uses PWM <Pulse Width Modulation>) technology. As the battery gets more charged up, it reduces the width of the charge pulse, but it never shuts off completely and dries out the batteries at least ten times faster than a 1.5 amp battery maintainer. So these solar controllers might be smart, but they work dumb when compared to a cheap 1.5 amp battery maintainer.
However, I see no reason why solar controllers cannot be made to shut totally off and on again as needed, just as with the battery maintainer. Or at least reduce the pulse width to so little that it cannot charge the battery at all, when not needed. It seems to not take much to dry the battery out, but I can leave one of these battery maintainers even on a motorcycle battery for years and almost never have to add water. On my Yamaha Venture battery, I added water to the battery once in three years with the battery maintainer. I think that would be about the same as if the battery wasn't even connected to anything, yet the battery is always held at it's peak with the battery maintainer. Seems just like a new battery for many years.
-Don-