So much action in this thread over the weekend! I will try to respond to everything, sorry if it is confusing and out of order.
Jan - Did your 29.2 come with the macerator? I am wondering if the dealer decides what extras come on the RV? I don't even see a macerator as an option on the ACE (http://acemotorhome.com/features.php). I also remember that my dealer was very surprised when he opened the sewer compartment and it was in there.
We picked and love the ACE for many reasons. We first started looking at it because of it's size, price and the overhead bunk. I grew up RVing with my grandparents and since I was so used to their layout I was looking for a lot of those features again. It worked so great back then so I knew it would for me now. Then after looking at many models we liked the styling of the ACE much better than the other options. It was more modern, inside and out. As we were narrowing down our choices (we only looked at A Class) we were down to the ACE & Hurricane. We picked the ACE b/c it seemed more higher end on many features, especially since it didn't have an air mattress for the sofa and bunk like the Hurricane did.
I really like the layout of the 29.2, where you have the conversation area (with sofa and dining room facing) and then the prep area next. Then I most definitely wanted my entire kitchen on one slide or at least all together. I didn't like where other models had part of the kitchen on one side and something like the fridge on the other. Also, having part of your kitchen on a slide seems very dumb to me. I like how the sofa folds down for a bed (this is exactly what my grandparents RV had) and the overhead bunk for when we had guests camping with us (which also has a pad and no air mattress). I too am not too thrilled with the round since in the kitchen or that it's white, but it wasn't so bad that it turned me off. The 30.1 had more counter space, but the fact that the TV was in the kitchen and the seating area was behind me turned me off that model. I am a huge cook at home so I was trying to be more relaxed and simple on camping trips. I wanted to step outside of my comfort zone and get used to a smaller space. The kitchen area worked really great for us on our first trip. I'm sure there will be times that I hate it but I think it has a great layout for us.
The bathroom and bedroom layout didn't play a huge part in our decision. We went back and forth about whether is was best to have everything in one room or a separate shower/toilet. In the end it wasn't that big of a thing for us to choose the 30.1 over the 29.2. As far as the bedroom, the horizontal layout gives you a lot more storage in the bedroom, but seems to leave you less in the rest of the coach. I always felt that if we had guests camping with us they wouldn't want to keep their stuff in our room, but up front with them. So to me I like the vertical layout where the storage was throughout the coach.
As far as the doggie feeding station. In the 29.2 this is inside the bathroom and out of the way, it's in the hallway in the other models. We have 3 dogs though so we won't ever use that. In our last trip, I didn't even notice it was there. It was never in the way.
As far as storage, I didn't look at the 29.1 at all (didn't like the kitchen configuration), but I thought they had about the same storage space as the 29.2. Either way, there is tons of storage for us. Inside and out. Yes, I would like to have a couple smaller compartments available outside, but the large compartment in the back is FANTASTIC. I know that everyone takes different amounts based on their family but for us (2 adults, 3 dogs), we have tons of space. So much more than I was ever expecting and space was a HUGE issue for me when shopping. We we loaded up for our first trip we had tons of cabinets inside that we weren't even using.
Overall, my husband and I find the ACE 29.2 to be very homey. When the slide is out and we are sitting there we just feel comfortable. Everything seems to be in just the right place for us. We do not regret our decision at all, this is the perfect coach for us. But obviously they made many different models because one type won't work for everyone!