I think where we lost out on the analog/digital switch mostly was in the fringe signal areas. An analog broadcast that was snowy but watchable, became unwatchable as a digital broadcast, even with the same transmitter power on the same frequency. We have an area station here in Upstate NY that broadcasts on VHF channel 6 for instance, that came in moderately well using the batwing on my motorhome in my yard before the changeover. After the change, they are still broadcasting on channel 6, and have even boosted their transmitter power somewhat, but the picture here was unwatchable due to severe pixilation until I added a secondary amplifier to the batwing amp. The other area stations are all on UHF channels now, and the Wingman add-on worked well for them, although the secondary amp has also made a couple of them more reliable in heavy rain, etc.