Hi Guys (and Ladies)
I just finished reading all of the comments on this subject and felt that I just had to put in my 2 cents Canadian
(that's 1 1/2 cents US).
First, I will introduce myself - I am a Nooby to the MH field, but not to PMTs.
I have been in the Sealant/Caulk business for over 40 years, working first for 2 manufactures (hands on) and then for the past 28 years, I have run my own business selling only sealant, caulking and coatings to various industries. You will notice below, that I refer to Sealant and Caulk, a number of times, which are different types of material. Most caulks (butyl, latex & siliconized latex) are capable of 10% movement before failing cohesively. Sealants, on the other hand, can withstand movement (stretching) of between 25-50% and even much higher.
Leaks around windshields and roofs have been one of the many headaches of most RV'rs. Most repairs are done several times to stop them. Most DIY have tried many types of Caulk or Sealant only to find large gobs of material are piled on top of other large gobs which have been applied to still smaller gobs.
The sealant around the windshield is a Urethane product, designed for Windshield installations. This product is a very high strength sealant to hold windshields in place and seal against from entering the cab. WINDSHIELDS DO NOT NORMALLY MOVE OR GET UNSEATED AFTER INSTALLATION. This can happen however, if the RV was subjected to rough road conditions causing racking or twisting. This is still quite rare. The formation of rust developing around the windshield channel or deteriation of the rubber gasket is more of a probability to cause of leakage. The use of silicone or butyl caulk is only a temporary fix. One thing to remember about silicone ----- only silicone will stick to silicone ! Do not use another sealant or caulk over silicone as it will not adhere to it. Another tip ---, remove old lose sealant/caulk before applying new material. When you apply sealant over sealant, your newly applied sealant, is only as good as the underlying sealant/caulk. The biggest cause of sealant failure is that the substrate was not cleaned adequately, causing loss of adhesion to some part of the newly applied sealant/caulk. The second cause of sealant failure is due to using the wrong product for the job. See my intro note above.
Dicor is a good sealant for roof repair ----- when it is applied correctly.
I will do a new post when I have time, on DIY roof repair and why you should do it yourself, rather than take it a repair shop - SOUND STRANGE??? Not really.
A bit of a teaser --- CRAYONS
Take care and Happy Motoring.